Monday, July 6, 2009

Preplanning Bank Burials

The Obama Administration wants the biggest of the big banks to start planning their own funerals.

Any bank such as Citigroup (C Quote), Goldman Sachs (GS Quote) and Bank of America (BAC Quote) that is considered too big to fail because of its size, leverage or the degree that its operations are interwoven into the fabric of the entire financial system would need to draft detailed plans for unwinding their operations should it ever come to that.

An analysis of the administration's proposed regulatory overhaul by the Associated Press concludes that the new scrutiny, larger cash cushions and asset requirements that the administration desires are intended to limit the number of systemically risky financial institutions by making it unappealing to get that big.

Essentially, the proposed requirements would pressure the financial system to deconsolidate -- a classic knee-jerk reaction to the financial bailout intended to make it less likely to be repeated.

Much like the bailout itself, these hastily concocted hangover cures may have many unintended side effects. The cure may eventually make us all feel worse than the sickness ever did.

It reminds me of the environment of corporate misdeeds that prompted the onerous Sarbanes-Oxley rules. What a mess that turned out to be -- even former Sen. Paul Sarbanes (D., Md.) and former U.S. Rep. Michael Oxley (R., Ohio) later told me that they regretted the extent of the regulatory changes they championed.

So here we go again. This time, everyone should all read the fine print and fully understand what they are signing, in particular the consequences.

What will happen if General Electric (GE Quote) is forced to exit from its GE Capital unit because of proposed limits on combined banking and commerce operations? How will the struggling car industry be impacted if Ford(F Quote), General Motors(GMGMQ Quote), et al. aren't able to provide financing to prospective buyers?

And just how many major institutions do we want to be trying to unload sundry parts of their operations to escape excessive government interference?

It seems like quite the muddle already with AIG (AIG Quote), Bank of America, Citi and others all trying with varying degrees of success and failure to sell pieces of their far-flung empires in order to repay taxpayers.

Pretty soon, President Obama may need to grab a gavel and add a new title to his resume -- "Auctioneer in Chief."

Or maybe "Undertaker in Chief" -- considering his desire for banks to plan their own burials.